Dialectical Behaviour Therapy (DBT) Vs Cognitive Behavioural Therapy (CBT)

Dialectical Behaviour Therapy (DBT) is a therapeuticTherapist Agreementso Make an effort to conduct
methodology developed by Linehan, a psychologycompetent Therapyo To be ethical and professional
researcher at the University of Washington to treatas per professional guidelineso To maintain
people with Borderline Personality Disorder (BPD). DBTconfidentialityo Obtain consent when necessaryo Be
combines Cognitive Behavioural Therapy withavailable for Therapy sessions and back up when
concepts of methodologies from various practicesneeded
including Eastern mindfulness techniques. Research has  None of these components are used by
shown that DBT is the first therapy that has beenthemselves. The individual component is considered
effective for treating BPD. Further research has beennecessary to keep suicidal urges or uncontrolled
carried out and appears to show that it is alsoemotional issues from disrupting group sessions, while
effective in treating people with spectrum moodthe group sessions teach the skills unique to DBT, and
disorders including self harming behaviour. Linehanalso provide practice with regulating emotions and
created DBT after realising that other therapies werebehaviour in a social context.
ineffectual when used for BPD. She recognised thatThe Four Modules
the chronically suicidal people that she worked withMindfulness
had been brought up in invalidating environments andMindfulness is one of the core concepts behind DBT. It
required unconditional acceptance in order for them tois the capacity to pay attention, in a non-judgmental
develop a successful therapeutic relationship. She alsoway, to the present moment. Mindfulness is all about
maintained that people need to recognise and acceptliving in the moment, experiencing one's emotions and
their low level of emotional functioning and be ready tosenses fully, yet with perspective. It is considered a
make a change in their lives.foundation for the other skills taught in DBT, because it
Helping the person with Borderline Personality Disorderhelps individuals accept and tolerate the powerful
to make therapeutic changes in their lives isemotions they may feel when challenging their habits
extraordinarily difficult for at least two reasons. Firstly,or exposing themselves to upsetting situations. The
focusing on patient change, either of motivation or byconcept of mindfulness and the meditative exercises
teaching new behavioural skill, is often experienced asused to teach it are derived from traditional Buddhist
invalidating by traumatised individuals and canpractice, though the version taught in DBT does not
precipitate withdrawal, non compliance, and drop outinvolve any religious concepts.
from treatment on the one hand, or anger, aggression,Interpersonal Effectiveness
and attack, on the other. Secondly, ignoring the needInterpersonal response patterns taught in DBT skills
for the patient to change (and thereby, not promotingtraining are very similar to those taught in many
much needed change) is also experienced asassertiveness and interpersonal problem-solving
invalidating. Such a stance does not take the very realclasses. They include effective strategies for asking
problems and negative consequences of patientfor what one may need, learning to say no, and coping
behaviour seriously and can, in turn, precipitate panic,with interpersonal conflict. Individuals with Borderline
hopelessness and suicidal ideation.  Personality Disorder frequently possess good
DBT involves two components:interpersonal skills in a general sense. The problems
1. An individual component in which the therapist andarise in the application of these skills to a specific
patient discuss issues that come up during the week,situation. An individual may be able to describe
recorded on diary cards, and follow a treatment targeteffective behavioural sequences when discussing
hierarchy. These sessions typically last for 45-60another person encountering a problematic situation,
minutes and are held weekly. Self Harming and Suicidalbut may be completely incapable of generating or
behaviours take first priority, followed by therapycarrying out a similar behavioural sequence when
interfering behaviours. After this there are issuesanalysing his or her own situation. The interpersonal
surrounding quality of life and working towardseffectiveness module focuses on situations where the
improving one's life in general. During the individualobjective is to change something (e.g., requesting that
therapy, both the therapist and the patient worksomeone do something) or to resist changes someone
towards improving skill use to survive and manageelse is trying to make (e.g., saying no). The skills taught
difficult feelings. The whole session should be workingare intended to maximise the chances that a person's
towards a setting that is validating for the patient. A lotgoals in a specific situation will be met, while at the
of attention should be paid to the immediate problems,same time not damaging either the relationship or the
feelings and actions. Often, a skills group is discussedperson's self-respect.   Emotion Regulation
and obstacles to acting skillfully are addressed.Individuals with Borderline Personality Disorder and
2. The group, which usually will meet once a week forsuicidal individuals are frequently emotionally intense
two to two-and-a-half hours, once a week, learns toand labile. They can be angry, intensely frustrated,
use specific skills which can be broken down into fourdepressed, or anxious. This suggests that these clients
modules: Core Mindfulness Skills, Interpersonalmay benefit from help in learning to regulate their
Effectiveness Skills, Emotion Regulation Skills, andemotions. Dialectical Behaviour Therapy skills for
Distress Tolerance Skills. The room should be arrangedemotion regulation include:o Identifying and labeling
like a classroom with the trainers (usually two) placedemotionso Identifying obstacles to changing emotionso
at the front. Issues and emotions are discussed andReducing vulnerability to emotion mindo Increasing
dealt with if they are life threatening or interfering withpositive emotional eventso Increasing mindfulness to
the group therapy. For example if someone iscurrent emotionso Taking opposite actiono Applying
behaving badly this would only be addressed if it wasdistress tolerance techniques  
causing a problem with the running of the group.Distress Tolerance
Otherwise, it would be ignored. Skills Training is runMany current approaches to mental health treatment
around a manual that gives details of the programmefocus on changing distressing events and
that has to be followed. This gives guidance andcircumstances. They have paid little attention to
advice about how it should be taught. It also containsaccepting, finding meaning for, and tolerating distress.
handouts for individuals. Group work can includeThis task has generally been tackled by
role-play and, as in CBT, homework is encouraged.psychodynamic, psychoanalytic, gestalt, or narrative
therapies, along with religious and spiritual communities
Commitment Before DBT can begin, the patients haveand leaders. Dialectical behavior therapy emphasises
to make a commitment to participate in the therapy.learning to bear pain skillfully.
This is an exercise in itself and may take severalDistress tolerance skills constitute a natural
meetings. Both the patient and the therapist makedevelopment from mindfulness skills. They have to do
explicit commitments. In practice, the therapist maywith the ability to accept, in a non-evaluative and
initially 'play hard to get' and lead the patient, tononjudgmental fashion, both oneself and the current
persuade him or her that the programme is indeedsituation. Although this is a nonjudgmental stance, this
justified.does not mean that it is one of approval or resignation.
People with BPD have often experienced treatmentsThe goal is to become capable of calmly recognising
that have been at best unrewarding. Consequentnegative situations and their impact, rather than
wariness needs to be validated and the newbecoming overwhelmed or hiding from them. This
therapeutic endeavour presented in a realistic way asallows individuals to make wise decisions about
promising but also demanding. Time spent onwhether and how to take action, rather than falling into
commitment before therapy is a good investment.the intense, desperate, and often destructive emotional
Likewise, if the therapeutic relationship becomesreactions that are part of borderline personality
wobbly or threatens to break down, then time needsdisorder.
to be spent on maintaining this commitment. It is usualSkills for acceptance include radical acceptance, turning
for there to be an agreement that if three consecutivethe mind toward acceptance, and distinguishing
sessions of one kind are missed for any reason thenbetween "willingness" (acting skillfully, from a realistic
the patient is out of the DBT programme.understanding of the present situation) and "willfulness"
Common Commitments in DBT(trying to impose one's will regardless of reality).
Patient Agreementso Agree a time limit to stay inParticipants also learn four crisis survival skills, to help
Therapyo Work towards reducing suicidal behavioursodeal with immediate emotional responses that may
Attend all Therapy sessionso Participate in Skillsseem overwhelming: distracting one-self, self-soothing,
Trainingimproving the moment, and thinking of pros and cons.